skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Very good soft-shell crab burger. Friendly staff when order take out by the phone.
Kathy Duong via google.com - Aug 9, 2020
Our first time at this place. The service from the time we entered to the food was simply amazing even our kids enjoyed it. Great $$. Its a much try. We will definitely be going back, loved it.
Shaleeza Amin via google.com - Aug 9, 2020
Great service and delicious food! The staff is beyond amazing, friendly and makes you feel at home!
Great service and delicious food! The staff is beyond amazing, friendly and makes you feel at home! It was our first time since we moved in the neighborhood and will definitely be our family's 1st choice for a delicious meal!
Nick De Castro via facebook.com - Aug 9, 2020
great place good food very nice people
great place good food very nice people ... read more
Joseph Nushawn Matthews via facebook.com - Aug 9, 2020
Had an issue with a food delivery a few days ago. Doordash driver spilled all our food while delive
Had an issue with a food delivery a few days ago. Doordash driver spilled all our food while delivering it and left it at the front door in an abysmal state. Contacted Popei’s and spoke to manager Joe who was very upset about the manner of delivery and offered his sincere apology as well as a refund on the dinner. Popei’s food as wel ... read more
James Peter via facebook.com - Aug 8, 2020
Our favorite seafood restaurant ...
Our favorite seafood restaurant.  We always order the mussels in garlic sauce as an appetizer followed by shrimp and filet of sole as the main dish. The garlic bread is delicious as well. Service is always top notch and the chef comes out and says hello to all the patrons.
Art J. via yelp.com - Aug 8, 2020
I'm so happy I came across this ...
I'm so happy I came across this place. Food was sooooo good. Oysters are fresh. Staff was amazing.
Estefany C. via yelp.com - Aug 7, 2020
food was excellent, friendly service. Great team of employees.
food was excellent, friendly service. Great team of employees.
Michele Macchia Miller via facebook.com - Aug 6, 2020
We googled it on the way home from out East. What a amazing find !! First of all the staff alone gives this place 5+ stars!! I’m a mom of two little babies and the staff was beyond kind and attentive to us !!! I will be back the food was amazing!! I don’t care if we live 40 minutes away. I will be back !!!
Nicole Wilkie via google.com - Aug 5, 2020
I have always enjoyed Popei’s and last weekend was no different! We had New England clam chowder, m
I have always enjoyed Popei’s and last weekend was no different! We had New England clam chowder, mussels in oil and garlic, linguini with clam sauce, and fried shrimp. Everything was delicious and I’m getting hungry just thinking about it :) ... read more
Joseph A. Kellermann via facebook.com - Aug 5, 2020
Amazing food everything is so tasty and the portions are very generous. Will highly recommend.
Christine Santos via google.com - Aug 2, 2020
We moved from Levittown to Long ...
We moved from Levittown to Long Beach, and Popeis still has the BEST seafood, and food overall.  We went back today,  and sat outside - food was delicious,  and the staff was amazing.   (I left my phone on the table , and the staff literally chased us before we pulled away - to give it back) ... read more
Jenny B. via yelp.com - Jul 31, 2020
Good food, best time to go is during pandemic because it isn't crowed like always ... read more
Bryant Lizardo via google.com - Jul 31, 2020
Went for dinner tonight, they did amazing with their outdoor setup. Very comfortable, big fans to k
Went for dinner tonight, they did amazing with their outdoor setup. Very comfortable, big fans to keep cool and keep bugs away, great lighting...the food is always amazing. The service was perfect! Definitely recommend and we will be back soon!!
Melissa Amy via facebook.com - Jul 30, 2020
Linguine with the Works in the ...
Linguine with the Works in the white wine sauce is a must! You get 6 kinds of seafood over a bed of al dente linguine. We also ordered the Marinara Madness (medium spicy) with mussels and clams over penne. They were both very fresh and the sauces were amazing. We finished two baskets of garlic bread amongst 4 people because we couldn ... read more
Kelly Z. via yelp.com - Jul 29, 2020
Love the workers and the food... I have nothing bad to say been going here for over 6 years and will continue for a long time to come ... read more
Joan Ng via google.com - Jul 28, 2020
I'll always always always order ...
I'll always always always order crab legs! The all you can eat crab legs is ok and the only thing that prevented me from giving 5 stars, the first batch of legs is amazing but then you start to get ones with the missing legs or just not the best cluster but still always the best legs!
Kelly M. via yelp.com - Jul 27, 2020
Had a awesome experience in here with my girlfriend. The food arrives rapidly and the customer service is just great. Prices are reasonable.
Luka Chaney via google.com - Jul 26, 2020
my wife and I just finished dinner. She had the Shrimp Spectacular and I had the seafood Fra Diaval
my wife and I just finished dinner. She had the Shrimp Spectacular and I had the seafood Fra Diavalo. Both dishes were great and plentiful. We were stuffed and had plenty of leftovers. Great job Popei's. In a sea of mediocrity you guys shine ... read more
James Ruggiero via facebook.com - Jul 25, 2020
Wow! What a seafood restaurant!!! Popei’s on Wantagh Avenue was nothing short of fantastic! I can
Wow! What a seafood restaurant!!! Popei’s on Wantagh Avenue was nothing short of fantastic! I cannot believe,I haven’t been here sooner. The wait staff, specifically Janice and Joe, were knowledgeable friendly, efficient, and hard working. Janice was attentive to us and was aware of spacing out our plates the entire meal. ⛺️ We a ... read more
Kristin Ann via facebook.com - Jul 25, 2020
Yum
my wife and I just finished dinner. She had the Shrimp Spectacular and I had the seafood Fra Diavalo. Both dishes were great and plentiful. We were stuffed and had plenty of leftovers. Great job Popei's. In a sea of mediocrity you guys shine ... read more
BigEman907 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 25, 2020
Amazing seafood option for the ...
Amazing seafood option for the area. Awesome nightly deals including all you can eat options which is always a plus. Fish is super fresh and pretty reasonably priced. The restaurant itself is a bit worn but who cares how it looks when it tastes good. A must try if you're in the area.
Mark G. via yelp.com - Jul 25, 2020
my wife and I just finished dinner ...
my wife and I just finished dinner. She had the Shrimp Spectacular and I had the seafood Fra Diavalo. Both dishes were great and plentiful. We were stuffed and had plenty of leftovers. Great job Popei's. In a sea of mediocrity you guys shine ... read more
James R. via yelp.com - Jul 25, 2020
Great food and service, highly recommend the stuffed lobster, popei sampler, and/or fried calamari. Haven't tried anything else yet.
Cedric W. via google.com - Jul 25, 2020
I absolutely Love Popeis! It never disappoints! The Atmosphere, the Quaintness, the Food, the Drinks.....and the Staff!!! From the Parking Lot to the Door to the Outside Dining! Yasssss!
Mercedes Murchison via google.com - Jul 24, 2020
My go to spot I been coming to ...
My go to spot I been coming to for years! Everything on the menu is fantastic, will not be disappointed. Prices are very reasonable, quick friendly service. Outdoor seating is nice.
Amira S. via yelp.com - Jul 23, 2020
This place hands down has the best king crab on the island! The owner is always present and makes everyone feel like family. Amazing staff, reasonable prices and delicious food. Love having dinner here! There's a reason you have to make a reservation, it's not the restaurants fault everyone wants a seat!!
Sarah K via google.com - Jul 22, 2020
Excellent food. Come here all the time.
Excellent food. Come here all the time.
Mike Caputo via facebook.com - Jul 21, 2020
Food is always amazing and on time; I have no complaints 🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤. A little pricey but its worth it!
Brenda Liz via google.com - Jul 21, 2020
Food is always good!!! And oh that garlic bread!
Food is always good!!! And oh that garlic bread!
Denise Tristano Pascalis via facebook.com - Jul 20, 2020
The best service ... read more
jameel jacobs via google.com - Jul 19, 2020
Amazing variety in dining.
Have dined here often. Inside and out. Family and friends. Take out also is excellent. Great Lobster bisque, New England and Long Is.clam chowder. Seafood, Lobsters, crabs, clams, steaks, burgers, pork shops, ribs, indicate the wondrous variety. The service is top notch.. Joe the owner...More ... read more
HarryG3645 via tripadvisor.com - Jul 15, 2020
Every year they are the best quality ...
Every year they are the best quality seafood restaurant on Long Island.  If it's not n the menu, just ask the owner and he'll make it for you.
Rick R. via yelp.com - Jul 14, 2020
Great food and service!!!
Amanda Steer via google.com - Jul 7, 2020
It’s a good place, decent food. Don’t expect fine dining, but it’s good. My margarita was excellent. Outdoor tent out back now too 👍🏼 ... read more
Just Chuck via google.com - Jul 7, 2020
The amount of amazing hospitality and friendly service is incomparable. From the moment you walk in you feel like family, even if it's your first time. All the staff have incredible positive attitudes, just sound like they're genuinely having a good time along with you. The food is excellent and the portions can be really huge. Some ... read more
Justin Bayoneto via google.com - Jul 7, 2020
I work close to this place, the outside intrigued be so I stopped by for lunch one day and have gone back multiple times since. Food is great, drink mixes are fun, outdoor patio is very comfortable and they were playing music at brunch which was very nice.
Charles Levine via google.com - Jul 6, 2020
Place is great food is always on the mark and the owner is top notch ... read more
Jim Koumou via google.com - Jul 5, 2020
The service is outstanding the owner couldn’t be more attentive and the seafood is spectacular love
The service is outstanding the owner couldn’t be more attentive and the seafood is spectacular love this place for over 20 years ... read more
Catherine Marciano via facebook.com - Jul 4, 2020
This place was a recommendation from a friend, and a very good one. Called while en route and was able to get a table Joe who took my reservation was very pleasant and cheerful. Choose to sit outside because of our new norm, the converted the parking lot in the back but it was quaint. The food was amazing and that went well with the ... read more
nadine jones via google.com - Jul 3, 2020
Very chill place, food was delish but drinks not worth their prices. Very friendly staff and clean
Very chill place, food was delish but drinks not worth their prices. Very friendly staff and clean place .... fast service and great atmosphere. Will come back again.
Michelle Delgado via facebook.com - Jul 3, 2020
Food was amazing....great plate of Alaskan king crab for 50 bucks ....Definitely going back ... read more
Brian Laffey via google.com - Jul 1, 2020
Moved to the area 29 years ago. The first place we visited was Popei's. New owner was Joe. He treat
Moved to the area 29 years ago. The first place we visited was Popei's. New owner was Joe. He treated us with kindness. Through the years as the kids grew so did our visits. Last night we visited again and Joe hasn't missed a beat. Still the same--goes from table to table and actually listens and cares about his guest which is so ref ... read more
Michael Walsh via facebook.com - Jun 30, 2020
Excellent food & excellent staff ...
Excellent food & excellent staff. We go for the weekly specials, but everything on the menu is very good. Highly recommend!
Rocio Q. via yelp.com - Jun 29, 2020
Joe, the owner was at our table several times to make sure everything was ok and it was DELICIOUS 😋
Joe, the owner was at our table several times to make sure everything was ok and it was DELICIOUS 😋 George, our server was awesome! It was so good to have a nice meal out with family and friends. 🦞 🍤 🍋 ... read more
Raina Arnold via facebook.com - Jun 28, 2020
This gem has the most amazing food ...
This gem has the most amazing food ! We dined there tonight for the first time in awhile and they have adapted to the new "norm" almost flawlessly. My family and I not only loved our delicious meals , we had the best waiter.  GEORGE was so attentive and such a great personality it made out whole experience that much better !! We will ... read more
Lisa M. via yelp.com - Jun 27, 2020
Great place for seafood and more! ...
Great place for seafood and more! I have been here more times than I know for dining in or taking out and was never disappointed.
Michael N. via yelp.com - Jun 26, 2020
What a fabulous time, great food, sangria and atmosphere. A definite visit spot after a rough couple of months. Staff is welcoming, accommodating and genuinely pleasant, which is nice. Safety precautions were in effect and the restaurant was spotless. Yes, I looked. I had ribs which were delicious, flounder was perfectly prepared for ... read more
Andrea Stewart via google.com - Jun 25, 2020
Went there for Father's Day dinner ...
Went there for Father's Day dinner. And as in the past they did not disappoint even though with the COVID situation eating outside and the efforts by the staff to make us comfortable was so beyond excellent .
We had the stuffed  lobster, broiled sea scallops ,
Fried calamari,
mussels and stuffed flounder .  All were deliciou ... read more
Stan J. via yelp.com - Jun 24, 2020
The food was AWESOME! Great staff, great food. My favorite seafood place!Placed an order last nigh
The food was AWESOME! Great staff, great food. My favorite seafood place! Placed an order last night and we were missing one item. I called and not only did they admit it was an error and replaced it, they gave us a very generous gift card for our troubles. That's how you do business.
Veronica Evert Bombria via facebook.com - Jun 22, 2020
Love this place! The food is great and the service is awesome!
Michelle Bellow via google.com - Jun 22, 2020
Dinner, staff & service was excellent. Enjoyed the outside seating. Will most definitely be going
Dinner, staff & service was excellent. Enjoyed the outside seating. Will most definitely be going back!
Nancy Palmer Girardi via facebook.com - Jun 22, 2020
Always the best food ! And they really handled COVID dining great !
Always the best food ! And they really handled COVID dining great !
Stan Jacobson via facebook.com - Jun 21, 2020
Had a wonderful dinner out on a ...
Had a wonderful dinner out on a Friday night!

I remember going to Popei's many, many years ago prior to my foodie years when I was just a child with my family. I remember mainly going for "late night" for the wonderful specials. That was over 20+ years ago, to my surprise, Joey, the owner recognized me!

The food last ... read more
Meri L. via yelp.com - Jun 20, 2020
I've never had a bad meal here...not ever ... read more
Keith Howell via google.com - Jun 19, 2020
Popei’s has done an excellent job setting up an outdoor dining experience for their customers durin
Popei’s has done an excellent job setting up an outdoor dining experience for their customers during these trying times.
Lois Culicelli via facebook.com - Jun 17, 2020
I’ve been coming to a Popei’s for well over a decade.. it’s my favorite restaurant and for good rea
I’ve been coming to a Popei’s for well over a decade.. it’s my favorite restaurant and for good reason, Great food excellent and friendly service, family owned and always fresh. You can’t beat it!! Never been disappointed here ever ... read more
Tara Isaacs via facebook.com - Jun 17, 2020
Popeis in Bethpage is open for outdoor seating and practicing very sanitary protocol. We went earl
Popeis in Bethpage is open for outdoor seating and practicing very sanitary protocol. We went early 530 so there were several empty tables. We love the food here! The owner/chef is super nice and the staff is very friendly. Id hate to see them have to close. Scrumptious scallops and fresh vegetables.
Sheryl Weiner Furman via facebook.com - Jun 15, 2020
Popei's is a top notch "out-east" ...
Popei's is a top notch "out-east" seafood spot, located in easy to get to Nassau county.

The food is on par with some of the best seafood restaurants out there. The price on the other hand , is very affordable. This is what makes this place such a steal.

Great service, easy to get seated; it's a great overall experien ... read more
Joe M. via yelp.com - Jun 15, 2020
Everything was great. Friendly service, great food, nice atmosphere
Everything was great. Friendly service, great food, nice atmosphere ... read more
Jennifer Torchetti-DiPrima via facebook.com - Jun 14, 2020
They make you feel like you're family. The service and food is outstanding. They are handling this virus situation as safe as possible.
Michael Beberman via google.com - Jun 13, 2020
outdoor dining, incredible food, fabulous wait staff
outdoor dining, incredible food, fabulous wait staff ... read more
Audra L Beberman via facebook.com - Jun 13, 2020
The best food and you can always ...
The best food and you can always count on popeis not once have we had problems. The freshest seafood around and the nicest wait staff as well. 10/10 ... read more
Josh J. via yelp.com - Jun 13, 2020
The food was beyond delicious. Ordered a seafood pasta dish. Got the Atlantic Ocean over a bed of pasta. Absolutely delicious.
KEN ALVAREZ via google.com - Jun 12, 2020
Plenty of food. And delicious
Plenty of food. And delicious ... read more
Margaret Polizzi via facebook.com - Jun 10, 2020
Absolutely love this place! I come ...
Absolutely love this place! I come here every time I am in the mood for seafood! Everything is always fresh and staff is very friendly. The wait is long most of the time but it is worth the wait!
Kaela L. via yelp.com - Jun 7, 2020
It is what I call a "Feel good" restaurant... large menu...amazing variety...from Italian dishes to
It is what I call a "Feel good" restaurant... large menu...amazing variety...from Italian dishes to seafood (fish, Lobster, King Crab Legs) & ribs... A personable wait staff that make you feel.like you're a VIP...Diners sing "Happy Birthday" to everyone who is celebrating. During this pandemic, Popei's takeout service has been so up ... read more
Randy Commish Gordon via facebook.com - Jun 6, 2020
Would definitely recommend trying this place. Great atmosphere, delightful food, excellent service. Highly recommended.
Ron Nye via google.com - Jun 5, 2020
Great food, great price!
Great food, great price!
Michael Berchoff via facebook.com - May 31, 2020
We ordered Dinner tonight for our anniversary. The food was absolutely fabulous.,and cooked to perf
We ordered Dinner tonight for our anniversary. The food was absolutely fabulous.,and cooked to perfection....The staff was amazing also... Thank You Brianna for taking our order. You truly are a valuable asset to Popei's clam bar. Your kindness was such a breath of fresh air, I am sure your boss is aware of how lucky he is to have yo ... read more
Keith Ferrara via facebook.com - May 29, 2020
Heard about this place from a Facebook ...
Heard about this place from a Facebook restaurant group, saw that they were offering curbside pick up during the pandemic, and had to try it on our anniversary.

Ordered from their special early bird menu and got the bucket of mussels w. garlic bread, shrimp parm w. linguine, fish tacos, and shrimp ceviche.  My faves were the s ... read more
D C. via yelp.com - May 28, 2020
Stop driving by this place. Pull over and have yourself a fantastic meal! Any time, even if they'
Stop driving by this place. Pull over and have yourself a fantastic meal! Any time, even if they're closing up soon, you and your guests are the most important people they want to serve. Ask Joe if they got a new Fireball delivery in. He'll get right on it!
Rob Imhoff via facebook.com - May 26, 2020
I have been there a few times and ...
I have been there a few times and I can say I was never disappointed. Great customer service. Awesome staff. Very attentive. The food is amazing. I'm talking about the shrimp scampi to the Lobster too even the cheeseburgers. They're also kid friendly. We had this amazing waitress Gaby who was out of this world. She was on top of ever ... read more
Dana M. via yelp.com - May 25, 2020
We are addicted and got so many of friends and family addicted!! The food is always cooked right an
We are addicted and got so many of friends and family addicted!! The food is always cooked right and delicious 😋 ... read more
Tina Masi Rodriguez via facebook.com - May 24, 2020
We ordered yesterday again! My boys said it was the best burger they had in a long time!! and we l
We ordered yesterday again! My boys said it was the best burger they had in a long time!! and we loved the lobster and muscles!! Yumm!!
Corinne Patricia via facebook.com - May 24, 2020
Great crab legs ... read more
Robne Peterson via google.com - May 23, 2020
Unbelievably Delicious
This pandemic allows for good hometown local favorites to keep feeding us A+ fresh seafood, pasta, crisp salads, appetizers (fish, cheese, etc) beverages to go! Staff is wonderful, friendly and get the order 100% spot on! Right off major Long island thoroughfares. A must try....More ... read more
nygrainbread via tripadvisor.com - May 23, 2020
Perfection. I been to this place ...
Perfection. I been to this place about 5 times. All dine in, and was never dissappointed. Yesterday my mom and I decided to get takeout from Popeis. I got the expecting lobster which was cooked to perfection. Its stuffed with lump crab and shrimp and stuffing. Mom got the broiled platter which was also delicious. They give u huge por ... read more
Christine T. via yelp.com - May 22, 2020
Joe is the Best and his staff rocks ...
Joe is the Best and his staff rocks..
Love this place.. Food is always fresh and delicious!!
Dan B. via yelp.com - May 20, 2020
Unlike that bad review Chris Jones gave this restaurant, which I saw. I would like to say that review reflects Christ Jones as a bad customer and you should be just be glad he won’t ever come back. You have been doing an amazing job feeding Long Island and since this covid-19 crisis began. You should be proud of your staff and y ... read more
James Brown via google.com - May 11, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire